If making two medium servings, set aside two small resealable jars. Here are the resealable glass jars that I use. If making one large serving, set aside one large jar.
Add all ingredients to the jar(s) of your choice, leaving enough room to stir. Or, add all ingredients to a mixing bowl for easier stirring, then pour into jars when done.
Stir until well mixed. Add any optional toppings except fruit. Seal jars.
Store overnight in the refrigerator for up to 5 days. Overnight oats will become thicker as each day passes. If desired, add non-dairy milk to thin it out. Enjoy cold, or heat in the microwave in 20-second increments until warm. Top with fruit before serving.
*If you prefer almond butter, try making your own Easy Homemade Almond Butter and using it in place of the peanut butter in this recipe.
**I prefer using coconut cream in overnight oats—it lends a thick, creamy and delicious texture. If using non-dairy yogurt, make sure to choose your favorite kind—the flavor will be very present. Use vanilla yogurt for a tasty addition!
Nutrition Information: is an estimate based on the best-selling, most common brands per ingredient. Also, it’s estimated based on 2 servings per recipe, made with 1 teaspoon maple syrup and without optional toppings.