Smooth, creamy and delicious—the best peanut butter protein shake! Made with just 4 ingredients.

How much peanut butter do you usually have on hand in your household? One jar, two jars? Maybe even three?

Erik and I usually have at least 16 jars on hand. Not to brag or anything… but, uh, being a food blogger has it’s (tasty peanut butter) benefits. Just sayin’. Lol!

We usually have so much peanut butter on hand because that’s what y’all love and can’t get enough of! And since I keep getting more and more requests for more flavors of protein shake recipes, I decided I’d combine both of your requests into one delicious peanut butter protein shake recipe.

Are you ready for the quickest, easiest, and totally protein-packed peanut butter protein shake recipe? Hint: this baby’s got 17 grams of protein per serving. Yep, I said it. 💪 And it only has 1.5g of sugar per serving. Say whaaaa?

How to Make a Peanut Butter Protein Shake

Making a super tasty, protein-rich peanut butter protein shake is easy! See for yourself:

Add Ingredients

Add all ingredients in the order listed in my recipe: non-dairy milk, vanilla vegan protein powder, peanut butter and ice cubes. Here’s the blender I use daily and seriously love.

Blend

Blend all protein shake ingredients together until smooth.

Enjoy

Pour into cups and enjoy the best peanut butter protein shake ever!

The 4 ingredients you need

Ingredient 1 – Non-dairy Milk

Ingredient 2 – Vanilla Vegan Protein Powder

Ingredient 3 – Unsalted, Natural Creamy Peanut Butter

Ingredient 4 – Ice Cubes

Perfect Snacks to go with your protein shake

In just minutes, you’ll enjoy the best peanut butter protein shake—just 4 simple ingredients and packed with 17 grams of protein.

Great Tools for the Best Peanut Butter Protein Shake

My Favorite Personal Blender – the best personal blender out there. I’ve used so, so many of them–expensive ones, cheap ones, mid-tier ones… and this is the blender that I love best and use daily to make my protein shakes.
Vanilla Vegan Protein Powder – one of my favorite plant-based protein powders. It’s protein-packed and made with veggies (but tastes kinda like vanilla ice cream). I calculated the nutritional value of 1 serving of today’s protein shake using this protein powder (17g protein per serving).
Best Vegan Protein Powder Review – curious about vegan protein powders? Check out my review of over 18 brands of vegan protein powder. I keep this guide updated and fresh with new vegan protein powders. 🙂

Soooooo… how’d you like learning all about today’s protein-rich peanut butter protein shake? You game? I’ll grab my 16+ jars of peanut butter, you grab the vegan protein powder, and I’ll meet you at the blender! 😉 Thankful & grateful that you’re here, sharing in these kitchen adventures with me. ‘Til the next one…

Sending you all my love and maybe even a dove, xo Demeter ❤️

☀ Click below to Pin ☀

📸 Did you make this peanut butter protein shake recipe? Take a pic and share it on Instagram with the hashtag #beamingbaker & tag @beamingbaker. I’d love to see it! 📸

More Delicious Protein Shakes